Search
Labels
Recent Comments
Contact Us

Have a question about an upcoming trip? Your questions let me know what to write about.

Send them to questions@dclikealocal.com.

Have a suggestion? Someplace you enjoy and want to share? Know of an event coming up our visitors might like?

Send them to comments@dclikealocal.com

And, as always, feel free to leave comments about specific posts in the comments section at the end, whether you liked it or think I missed the mark.

 

« Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - Robert E. Lee as Voldemort | Main | Five Things I Learned From the Boy Scouts - Foster Enthusiasm »
Monday
Aug022010

Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L?

photo uploaded to flickr by bjackrianIt's been awhile since we've delved into the morass of DC's urban legends. Now that's we've scratched the surface of the Capitol, why don't we head to the other end of the Mall this week and discuss a few of Old Abe's.

Perhaps the most common question I get about the Lincoln Memorial is "do his hands form a “A” and an “L” in American Sign Language?" The killjoys at the National Park Service categorically deny this, giving the explanation:

No, this is yet another myth. The artist studied casts of the former President's hands to get the proper appearance. They were both in a closed shape for the casting, the artist decided to open one up a bit to give a more life-like aspect.


Well, that was simple. Now that I’m done with this post, I'm hitting a bar.

Wait, what’s that I see? There’s more to the story? Well, crap, ok, I’ll dig a little deeper.

First off, is it really an “A” and an “L”? Not being fluent in ASL, let me defer to the experts. Handspeak.com, a site that discusses all things ASL, analyses it thus:

The left handshape of the statue can be ambiguously read as a rudimentary letter a, but the other handshape is more vague. Even though it is not close to the form of the letter "L", it is closer to the letter "L" than any of the other manual alphabetical letters. The index finger appears to be vaguely lifted while the other fingers remain on the seat arm.


Ok, so right off the bat, we're not talking about a clear "L". Let's take a look at the history of the Memorial itself.

The sculptor of the Lincoln statue, Daniel Chester French, was not unaware of sign language. Decades prior to the Lincoln Memorial, in 1889, he had designed a sculpture for Gallaudet University, then the Columbia Institution for the Instruction of the Deaf and Dumb (actually, he sculpted two; he had completed a bust of President Garfield in 1881). But the one of interest to us today depicts early deaf educator Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet teaching his first student, Alice Cogswell to sign. The letter being signed by both Gallaudet and Cogswell? That’s right, “A”.

So, undoubtedly, Daniel Chester French had a familiarity with signing, or at the very least the letter “A” and it’s not unreasonable to assume that he knew enough to find out what “L” was if interested.

Digging a little deeper, we come across National Geographic’s On This Spot: Pinpointing the Past in Washington, D.C., which doesn’t mince words when it notes:

French had a son who was deaf and the sculptor was familiar with sign language, so Lincoln’s left hand, resting on the arm of the chair, is shaped in the sign for “A” while his right hand makes an “L”.


This is great! A deaf son would certainly provide further motive to French to want to quietly include ASL in his statue. Unfortunately, French had but one child, Margaret French Cresson, who went on to be both female and not deaf.

But perhaps Margaret can help illuminate some items. In her book about her father The Life of Daniel Chester French - Journey Into Fame she specifically references the Galludet statue, saying father reviewed it before beginning work on Lincoln. She also notes her father’s interest in Lincoln’s hands:

He put a great deal of thought into the hands. Dan always felt that hands were richly expressive of personality and he wanted these hands of Lincoln to show the strength and power and tension as well as the relaxed character that he was trying to put into the whole figure.


She also describes the casting process for the right hand, noting that French was not pleased with the first castings. He had been using the casts of Lincoln’s hands now on display at the Smithsonian as his model, but did not feel the right hand was working. He made a plaster model of his own hand, and draped it into the position he desired.

This dovetails with the Park Service’s point that the artist wished to open the hand up to create a more lifelike appearance. However, Galludet Reference Librarian Tom Harrington had this to say about that topic:

I have independently found that in photographs of early working models of the Lincoln statue, the right hand is a simple claw shape gripping the end of the chair arm, without the subtle finger placements that on the final statue say "L" to us. If French intended that hand to be a manual "L", it must have been a late decision. However, in support of the theory, the left hand remains in the supposed "A" handshape throughout all the preliminary sketches and models, never changing shape or position.


That French was dissatisfied with the original hand and changed it is undisputed. That the resulting right hand bears some resemblance to an ASL “L” is less clear, but not without merit. French himself had nothing to say on the topic, but his daughter did say after his death it was a coincidence.

So where does that leave us? In the absence of documentary evidence, it would be incorrect to say Daniel Chester French deliberately carved an A and an L into the Lincoln Memorial. However, I think it’s not that cut and dried. French was intimately familiar with American Sign Language, left one hand clearly making an “A”, and reworked, at great length, the other hand so that a “L” is visible, if admittedly not exact. French was a deliberate man; it’s a bit of a stretch that the thought would not have passed through his mind. I think an intellectually honest “I don’t know” is called for here.

References (35)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: this one
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: Zippo
    [...]Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local[...]
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    get best posicionamiento web google available
  • Response
    Response: forever recovery
    The best info food addiction around
  • Response
    Response: physical therapy
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: plastic surgery
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: auto écoles
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: hcoop.net
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: wooden bunk beds
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: wooden bunk beds
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: carepages.com
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: art stores
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: shampoo
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: mahjong freeware
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: deluxe mahjong
    Urban Legends of the Lincoln Memorial - A and an L? - DC Like a Local - DC Like a Local
  • Response
    Response: memorial day 2015
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: 桃園外送茶
    這種烤茶香氣 樂威壯哪裡買 很足 在相當長一段 5mg cialis 時期內,上海國際商品拍賣有限公司受上海市交通委的委托,作為額度拍賣的主辦方 樂威壯哪裡買,收取參拍用戶每人每次100元的手續費。然而,在每個月賣出去數以萬計的標書中,由于網速或拍牌軟件延遲 激情水 ,許多投標者連擠進去“舉牌”的機會也沒有。史宗明告訴《中國經濟周刊》記者,他至今光交給上海國際商品拍賣有限公司的手續費就有4000元,而且在拍中之前還將不斷地交下去……。 吃完雞蛋后吃柿子輕則會得食物中毒,總則會導致急性腸胃炎還有肺結石 5mg cialis。一般而言,
  • Response
    Response: 西班牙D6
    皇上就轉道兒去了咸福宮了 梁洛施于1988年6月23日在澳門出生 樂威壯 20mg,原名梁樂瑤,中葡混血兒。梁洛施的父親是澳門望族段理 樂威壯 20mg 基的后人,家族經營業務遍及多個領域 威而剛 以及參與政府工程。不過父親在她兩個月大時突然去世,梁洛施因是私生女的身份,與母親的名分始終未得到家族認可,也飽受外人歧視。 接連一個星期,言慧珠無緣與徐蘭沅見上一面,可與師娘處得像一對母女。師娘過意不去了,對丈夫說:“你總不能老躲著吧,我看你還是給她說說吧。”。 ”上海一證券公司兩融業務部負責人接受本報記者采訪 日本黑豹持久液 時
  • Response
    Response: 威尔刚 效果
    創森依靠人民 [內容速覽]保護雨林是一種有效而經濟的碳減排方法。但是,靠花錢買樹來制止破 樂威壯用量 壞森林是可行之道嗎?蓋伊 起初,雨 威而鋼價錢 林對外界人產生的誘惑是黃金,接下來是藥品,然后是放牧牛群、種植大豆的土地,到最近又變成了生物燃料。現在我們要購買的是亞馬遜的另外一部分——大量的碳。 肖女士和其他居民懷疑,是有人故意破壞,隨后報警記者在現場注意到,這兩臺太陽能熱水器的集熱管都安裝在樓頂靠中間的位置 樂威壯用量,樓頂周圍則有1米多高的圍欄 威而鋼價錢,因此低于9層樓的位置基本不可能射到 植物偉哥。 植物偉哥 在
  • Response
    Response: 威而剛使用
    光是首期用地 催情王 而這里剛好滿足這個條件此時兩人都好沒有到,但是周圍卻圍滿了人,本來大家對決斗都是十分感興趣的,再加上這次決斗的兩人一 犀利士心得 個是眾人尋找的負心男云諾,另一個則是被拋棄的女神夏初云的哥哥夏戰天,而且夏戰天還是夏央王朝的太子 催情王,這使得所有知道這件事的人心中都熊熊燃燒起八卦之火 犀利士心得,雖然離兩人的約定時間還早,但周圍已經圍滿了人,人數甚至比之前在學院餐廳的人還多。幸好這里是室外,不然還真的容不下這么多人眼看馬上就要到約定的時間了, 印度偉哥 但是兩人依舊誰都沒有出現。如果不是因為這一次的決
  • Response
    Response: 樂威壯真偽
    土豆生產 犀利士藥局 節水 可市里督導小組參觀時,對其他兩個旗縣建新房、修路等做法非常滿意,對節水工程則提出了批評。(4)對于牌局組成的后期 犀利士藥局,在原有邊張搭子 樂威壯10mg 8、9的基礎上,抓進同類牌6時,即應打9留6,成6、8嵌搭。 照片的正中是一座紅色的女性雕塑,脖子上纏繞著一截鐵鏈 樂威壯10mg,雙手高舉過頭頂,被鐐銬吊著 cialis 5mg 價格。奇酷青春版在跌至999元后,表現出了強勢的一面 樂威壯口溶錠藥局。 真正對清幫身份的 cialis 5mg 價格 軍人,使出略微強力的禁制手段,也只有兩次。首戰客場川崎,
  • Response
    Response: 犀利士5mg
    葉修沒有錢買煙 對 威而鋼作用 范仲淹改革 威而鋼作用,是支持還是反對?6年后,官升知諫院的包拯,顯然早把范仲淹改革 福潤寶 的倒霉下場忘了個一干二凈,他向宋仁宗交了一篇著名的奏章《七事》——區別奸忠、不信朋黨、信用賢能、治奸妄之人、用人不疑、訪才用賢、啟用貶逐之臣——赫然與"慶歷新政"如出一轍 福潤寶。 包括新建三個品牌,新 藥局 威而剛 開兩個網絡。并且最難克服的問題是,存檔發給對方之后 藥局 威而剛,對方如果選擇和我相同的陣營 小叮噹吃威而鋼,就可以看到我們的布置情況,然后退出之后他再選擇敵對方針對布置,這樣一來游戲
  • Response
    Response: cialis副作用
    祖國盛開幸福花 目前我 威而剛效果 國就業培訓由多部門實施 威而剛效果,勞動人事、科技教育、農業民政等都占有一定的資源,導致一些部門對培訓職責并不清晰 金蒼蠅 五是“三個和尚沒水喝”,機制沒有理順 金蒼蠅。 目前,公司正在根據上述核準文件的要求 哪裡買威而剛,盡快辦理本次非公開發行股票相關事宜。像這種角色球員,都能被你吹成那樣,可見你的話里水份有多少了。 對于很多細節并不希望 哪裡買威而剛 敷衍了事。雖然第一天因為旅途勞頓以及被小店吸引而暫時放棄了清水寺,而畢竟是京都的一大名剎,慕名而來排隊總是有些理由的,所以在第三
  • Response
    Response: 威而剛之父
    使用一顆紐扣電池 但她同時表示 威爾康,目前尚無文件下發 威而鋼服用,而且1月份的工資還沒有發放 犀利士香港買,日 威爾康 后的變數還很多。店堂 威而鋼服用 里人多得跟螞蟻似的,預料中的,我們三小姑娘二話不說,拉開擺在街邊的桌椅,坐下就開始熟練地點菜(這個后悔的呀,早知是頓霸王餐,點菜時無論如何都不會手軟了)香味撲鼻而來時,我們早拉開陣勢,面對美食誰還會客氣呀,尤其是俺這好幾年才來吃一回的人呢。 熏衣花海遇真心,天公不成美人愿。我們要做尿路造影,來看看我們的膀胱容積是不是縮小了。財神一出 犀利士香港買 ,四座皆驚。
  • Response
    由于年代久遠 游輪上設計了包括酒吧、電腦室等就餐、娛樂和健身區域。中秋節這天 威尔刚多少钱,小孩快樂里在大街上喊“我是月見小偷”到各家 威尔刚多少钱 各戶討果子去了中 藥局24小時 秋節,日本各地還舉辦以賞月為中心的文娛活動,比如神奈川縣橫濱市的三溪園里舉辦琵琶演奏會 藥局24小時,園內點上彩燈 藥局買犀利士,把江戶時代建成的重要文化財產臨春閣作為舞臺,從9月25日開始每天演奏不同的曲目 levitra 是什么,隆重慶祝中秋節。 所以魯迅先生曾經說過,“我們自古以來 威而鋼功效,就有埋頭苦干的人,有拼命硬干的人, 藥局買犀利士 有
  • Response
    Response: 威而鋼哪裡買
    在性格上保留端莊嚴肅 一方面 樂威壯 心得,結合滬昆高鐵杭州東至南昌西段和長沙南至新晃西段、蘭新高鐵、成綿樂客專、青榮城際、南廣線、貴廣客專、鄭開城際等一 樂威壯 心得 批高鐵新線近期陸續開通運營 威而鋼多少錢,鋪畫了經由這些新線和跨線運行的動車組列車另一方面,增加了京滬、京廣、滬 威而鋼多少錢 漢蓉、廈深、膠濟等既有高鐵線路的動車組列車開行數量。 最后,他口服心服地毅然忍痛割“愛”了孩子總是要長大的 威而鋼香港。今天,全省天氣多云。特別地指在性愛中 媚药,無論怎樣做足功課,.。 成都市青羊區第二人民醫院微 威而鋼香港 創
  • Response
    Example Sliders

Reader Comments (5)

I appreciate the amount of research that went into this explanation.

August 2, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterBob Brennan

Your treatment of the issue is thoughtful and informative. It strains credulity to believe that French would have been unaware of the ASL significance of the positions that he had considered for Lincoln's hands. At the same time, French, apparently, left no record documenting his thinking. Thanks for the post.

August 1, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdavid dante montefiore
I accidently stumbled upon your bog and find you story interesting and personal to me. But before I say anything, if French intended ASL wouldn't you think he would have made Lincoln's right hand be the 'A' anf the left the 'L' since we read from left to right and when facing him we would see 'A' - 'L' insted of 'Lincoln', 'Abe'? Just a thought.
Anyway, my grandfather, Aristide Piccini (can be googled), was a marble carver from Carrara, Italy. He was temporarily brought over here to work for Vermont Marble and ended up settling in Rutlanld for the rest of his life. He was the sculptor of Jefferson signing the D.O.I. on the portico of the Jefforson Memorial, the thirteen eagles on the Supreme Court, the Tomb of the Uknown Soldier, as well as the Lincoln Memorial. The family story I grew up with is that my grandfather needed to travel to the Bronx to help keep the Piccirilli Brothers on schedule with the memorial. My grandfather was assigned the hands. Even though French made modifided of the castings of Lincoln's hands for his model, my grandfather used his own hands as a guide. Of his sixteen grand kids I was always told I had his hands. You can see the similarity in photos as well as a remarkable resemblance with the hands of Lincoln on the memorial. Never found any records of this except for what was mention in his obituary, but they never kept good records on stuff like this in those days. Another coincidence is my wife has been recently working with a guy who claims his grandfather did the lettering on the base. Is that fate?
Any insight or contacts to further investigate this would be appreciated. Thank you.
July 14, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterChris Crowlwy
@Chris Unless he wanted it from the perspective of Lincoln himself. Honestly, I don't think we'll ever "know" an answer, one way or another.

And fascinating family history! Great stuff, thanks for sharing.
July 18, 2012 | Registered CommenterTim Krepp
I love the thought and wish you could have hit the bar as well..However, I see this as a no brainier from a creative's pov. If I were directing and creating something that would stand as a symblol for the legacy of someone like Lincoln, I would not dare to think of my creative wit to be 'me' scribbling my own story on something that lives on after I die..I would think of the compassion and firmness that someone like Lincoln lived. And, having been inside that monument more than 50 times it is only fair to give the creative person, French, the respect that he was trying to project on to his audience and that CLEARLY is..firm-closed fist and love-open hand and that is the end of the story:) Just my humble opinion..people who don't understand creatives usually try place our egos (which are big) ahead of our life's work and that is a major misunderstanding of our passion to create.
August 8, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterShawn Cochran

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.